Skip to content
Ali Sedighi

Fractional executive, agency or full-time hire: how to choose

The honest comparison of cost, speed, accountability and risk for a company between $2M and $30M that needs senior leadership in a function.

When marketing, finance or operations outgrows the owner, there are three ways to fill the gap. Each is right for a different situation, and the wrong choice is expensive in different ways.

Full-time hire

Best when the function is large enough to need someone every day and the company can afford a senior salary plus benefits, typically $150K to $250K all in for a real executive. The risk is a mis-hire: six months and a severance to find out.

Agency

Best for execution capacity in a defined channel: ads, SEO, content, development. Agencies are accountable for output, not for the strategy or the P&L. If nobody senior on your side sets direction, agencies optimise what they were asked to optimise.

Fractional executive

Best when the company needs senior decisions and systems but not 40 hours a week of them. A fractional CMO or CFO costs a fraction of a hire, starts in weeks, and builds the function so it can eventually be handed to a full-time person. The risk is choosing someone who advises but does not operate.

A simple rule

  • Under $2M: owner plus specialists and an advisor
  • $2M to $10M: fractional executive plus agency or in-house doers
  • $10M to $30M: fractional executive building toward a full-time hire
  • Above $30M: full-time leadership with fractional specialists

By Ali Sedighi, MBA. 5 minute read.

Start with a 30-minute strategy call.

Tell us where the business is and where it should be in 12 months. You leave with two or three specific moves, whether or not we work together.

Call Strategy call